Greed is Good?


I know, cliche to use a movie titled “Wall Street” in a blog post about comparing a film to business ethics. But I couldn’t help but draw the direct ‘shareholder wealth vs stakeholder’ analogy to the 1987 blockbuster hit. The movie portrayed a wall street millionaire/billionaire, corporate-raiding Gordon Gekko, and the journey of a young stock broker named Bud Fox.

Bud Fox desperately wants in the game of wealth,  and Gekko acts as a mentor to the young and naive Fox. Gordon Gekko shows Fox the art of generating super wealth, despite teaching him to perform illicit acts such as inside trading. Gordon Gekko publicly preaches that “greed is good,” and argues that one would be naive to think we live in a democracy, but rather a free market. He teaches Bud Fox that ‘getting your hands dirty’ is necessary to survive, compete, and succeed.

Gekko feels no sympathy for the companies he buys and dissolves, leaving so many unemployed. Gordon Gekko sacrifices these stakeholders at the expense of his own personal gain. Here is the scene in which Bud Fox confronts Gekko, after Gekko double-crosses Fox and decides to dissolve the company  (BlueStar airlines) his father currently works for, despite promising the Fox family he would buy and expand it.

On a more analytical note, Gordo’s “Greed is Good” motto technically makes sense, especially in a free capitalist market spurred by competition and innovation. In other words, the more selfish the corporations (in terms of shareholder wealth), the more competition is forced to keep up, creating a stronger economy as a whole.

The problem occurs when business ethics are ignored and stakeholders are sacrificed at the expense of wealth. Many would say human rational naturally leans towards greed and wealth, but there will always be those that are stakeholder-first, hence Fox’s motivation to seek revenge on Gekko. Milton Friedman, like Gekko, believed in the ‘invisible hand,’ but also stressed one must STAY WITHIN THE RULES at all costs. Gekko broke the rules, and made many enemies along the way, which ultimately came back to bite him in the ass.

Advertisements

6 thoughts on “Greed is Good?

  1. I think this movie depicts the extreme form of Milton Friedman’s shareholders ethic. Yet, we still know the majority of the investors are putting short-term personal gain as a top priority. The movie justified it with a tragic ending to Gekko; so, the takeaway is the business should be run responsibly.

  2. I’m kind of surprised you have seen such an “old” movie. Do you watch lots of mid 1980s movies?

    It may be even that Gecko’s speech was modeled on the Friedman essay. I may have heard that once. I wonder if anyone can research it.

  3. I really liked your blog this week. I have never seen this movie and based on the clip you provided I’d really like to watch the whole thing. The question that Fox keeps asking Gekko in the video is “how much is enough”? Gekko isn’t quite capable of answering that question and just avoids it. The reason is because for someone who preaches that “greed is good,” the answer is simply that nothing will ever be enough.

  4. I’ve seen this movie many times, but the way you described it was interesting because it made me feel like there were similar themes to Training Day, arguably my favorite Denzel Washington movie. I had never thought of that comparison, so thanks.

  5. Hi Austin I could not agree is more. I think greed is a major issue when it corrupts people and they decide to act unethically. I think that the better word to use instead of greed is good is motivation is good as this provides that same push to be the best, but you are not blinded by what happens.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s